About Potion
We're a small company run by a group of friends who love Magic: The Gathering. We built the shop we always wanted: fair prices and a seamless buying experience.
We love this game and we want to help you find the cards you're looking for. Search our catalog, use Mass Entry to paste your decklist, and check out in seconds. Every card is carefully packaged and shipped with tracking.
Card Condition
We think traditional condition grades are theater. What's Near Mint (NM) to one seller is Lightly Played (LP) to another, and what's Lightly Played (LP) to them might be Moderately Played (MP) to you. The range is too wide, too vibes-based, and it's often used to justify higher prices rather than describe the actual card.
We simplified it: every card we sell is "Play Ready", meaning Lightly Played (LP) or better. Clean fronts, clean backs, no major wear. Cards you can sleeve up and play with confidence.
If you're chasing a perfect 10/10 for your collection, graded cards exist for exactly that purpose. We believe Magic cards are meant to be played and enjoyed, and that's what we're here to help you do.